How come every time you call me baby
Something's wrong and I feel crazy?
Feel like jumping out of the car
A kiss goodnight, why do I have to
Make me close my eyes? I force a daydream
I was close but no cigar

Message in a bottle
Keep it cryptic, my bravado
When you kiss me I kiss back
You tell a joke, I fake a laugh

And you ask me if I'm in this
I'm talking like a politician
I swear it always feels too soon
To do right, tell the truth

How the hell did I let this get so far?
I'm an angel in your eyes
I can't believe I got you crying
I'm lying while I'm lying in your arms
Got the devil by my side
Saying please don't break his heart
Don't break his heart
Don't break his heart

Last week you let me drive us down the highway
In your car without a license
For a moment it felt right
But how come when we pulled up to the party
And you put your arms around me
I started searching for exit signs?

Message in a bottle
See me running from our problems
Swear it always feels too soon
To do right, tell the truth

How the hell did I let this get so far?
I'm an angel in your eyes
I can't believe I got you crying
I'm lying while I'm lying in your arms
Got the devil by my side
Saying please don't break his heart
Don't break his heart
Don't break his heart

Don't break his heart
Can you feel it?
Can you feel it?
Can you feel me, yeah
Disappearing
Disappearing
Disappearing, yeah
Can you feel it?
Can you feel it?
Can you feel me, yeah
Disappearing
Disappearing
Disappearing

How the hell did I let this get so far?
I'm an angel in your eyes
I can't believe I got you crying
I'm lying while I'm lying in your arms
Got the devil by my side
Saying please don't break his heart
Don't break his heart
Don't break his heart