You said you can't be trusted
I was safe inside 'til I gave you the key
When everything about me had adjusted
I stood there looking out into the sea
Then, pulling out a pencil from your pocket
You drew our names in cursive in the sand
There's nothing I could do to stop you
You held me like a seashell in your hand

Go back to sleep, it's just a dream
I'll be here when you wake
Your lullaby was all a lie
I believe it just the same

When did I become your hostage?
Won't you tell me what it is that you demand?
You say you had an answer and you lost it
You need to go and find it once again
You held my hand and walked me to the water
Then pointed to an island on the map
Then folded it and put it in your pocket
And promised one day soon you would be back

Go back to sleep, it's just a dream
I'll be here when you wake
Your lullaby was all a lie
I believe it just the same

Go back to sleep, it's just a dream
I'll be here when you wake
Your lullaby was all a lie
And I won't be fooled again
No, I won't be fooled again