How can you make it look so easy
Leavin' like you did
How am I supposed to move on
With you gone like this
They tell me I should stitch it back up
And give it away to somebody new
But it don't work that way
'Cause you only get one true love, girl
And that was you

If I had two hearts
One wouldn't be broken
If I had two hearts
One would still be mine
On my sleeve out in the open knowing someday I'd be fine
But if I had one more to give you baby I know what I'd do
Oh-oh-oh, Oh-oh-oh, Oh
I'd let you break that one, too
Right in two

I'd leave the door wide open
And open a bottle of wine
And then I'd let you lead me on
Baby one more time
Girl, I'd give you all my love
Let you back in
Mess me up and do it all again
Even though I know exactly how this ends

If I had two hearts
One wouldn't be broken
If I had two hearts
One would still be mine
On my sleeve out in the open knowing someday I'd be fine
But if I had one more to give you baby I know what I'd do
Oh-oh-oh, Oh-oh-oh, Oh
I'd let you break that one, too

Right into a million pieces on the floor
What's the difference
I can't fix this
I just don't wanna be heartbroken anymore, yeah

If I had two hearts
One wouldn't be broken
If I had two hearts
One would still be mine
On my sleeve out in the open knowing someday I'd be fine
But if I had one more to give you baby I know what I'd do
Oh-oh-oh, Oh-oh-oh, Oh
I'd let you break that one, too
Right in two