I found her picture in his dresser
As though he'd put it there to find
And the moment that I saw her
There was no doubt in my mind
I just stood there shakin'
My whole world about to change
When I laid it on the table
I watched his tears as he explained:

He said her name is Sarah
And her eyes are ocean blue
She's almost three years old now
And thinks I hung the moon
A thousand times I've tried to tell you
But it'd break your heart to know the truth
I just pray you can forgive me
And come to love Sarah too

It happened a long time ago
When things between us weren't right
And I swear it was one time
Sarah was made that night
And all those times I've told you
"It was just a Sunday drive"
I was going to see my little girl
That precious secret in my life

In a way I'm glad you know now
I didn't wanna lie
But girl, I couldn't lose you
And he looks me in the eye and said

He said her name is Sarah
And her eyes are ocean blue
She's almost three years old now
And thinks I hung the moon
A thousand times I've tried to tell you
But it'd break your heart to know the truth
I just pray you can forgive me
And come to love Sarah too

I just pray you can forgive me
And come to love Sarah too

He said her name was Sarah.