You were all done up
But it wasn't for me
You were up at the front
To tap on your feet

I was back at the bar
You had your eyes on the stage
You had an X on your hand
To tell them your age

I didn't put my money on it
But I was hoping that you would be here
If I was something that you ever wanted
Then I'm all ears
I'm all ears

You made a wish at 11: 11
I held your hips at 12: 34
There was a kiss just waiting to happen
A cab was calling outside the door
And oh, I knew from the beginning
Oh, it was you from the beginning

Excuse the disguise
Or the ones before
I've been convincing myself
There could be something more

If you go home and get on the phone
And tell your girlfriends about me
Then I'll go home and sleep on my own
And dream on a girl named Lonnie

I couldn't hold a candle to you
And you were glowing in the dark
I was nervous just standing with you
You were glowing in the dark

You made a wish at 11: 11
I held your hips at 12: 34
There was a kiss just waiting to happen
A cab was calling outside the door
And oh, I knew from the beginning
Oh, it was you from the beginning

And you weren't even trying
Your dirty blonde hair, it had me going wild
You were a little bit shy then
There's no denying something so true

You made a wish at 11: 11
I held your hips at 12: 34
There was a kiss just waiting to happen
A cab was calling outside the door
And oh, I knew from the beginning
Oh, it was you from the beginning

It was you from the beginning