We were just talkin' in the car
And by "talkin'", I mean I was talkin' to myself
But I swear I heard you say that there's been no one else
Who makes you feel okay like I did
I know it's crazy on my part
'Cause now I'm cryin' in the middle of an intersection
And I can hear you say, "Maybe not in the intersection"
So, I pull over for a minute

And now I'm three years in, it still feels weird
Wonderin' why I'm still here

Can I just shut up about it?
I said, "I'm over it" but hate the way it sounded
I know you're someone else, somebody I don't know
But I'm still talkin' like it happened just a week ago
'Cause I keep dancin' around it
I know my state of mind just isn't where the ground is
'Cause now I'm someone else, somebody you don't know
But I keep cryin' like we're still the seventeen-year-olds
(Can I just—?)

I've been stayin' back at home
Half a mile from the place I know you're livin' now
And you know me and how I can't help but just blame myself
For anything that I can think of
(For anything that I can think of)
Oh-oh-oh, maybe I'm just scared that if I let you go
I realize there's somethin' better out there or I won't and
Either way, I'm not down for more tears than right now
So I'll stick to fightin' this fight with myself

Can I just shut up about it?
I said, "I'm over it" but hate the way it sounded
I know you're someone else, somebody I don't know
But I'm still talkin' like it happened just a week ago
'Cause I keep dancin' around it
I know my state of mind just isn't where the ground is
'Cause now I'm someone else, somebody you don't know
But I keep cryin' like we're still the seventeen-year-olds

Can I just shut up about it? (Mm)
Can I just (Can I just?) shut up about it?

Maybe I'm crazy for thinkin' you miss me
'Cause you could be out there with some other girl
Think I'd be happy for you 'til you're happy
With someone who actually fits in your world (You rude)

Shut up about it?
I said, "I'm over it" but hate the way it sounded
I know you're someone else, somebody I don't know
But I'm still talkin' like it happened just a week ago

Can I just? (Shut up) Shut up about it?
(Shut up, shut up, mm)
Can I just (Can I just?) shut up about it?
(Shut up, shut up, shut up)